Defending the Nixticuil Forest

Polyphonic Story of a Foreclosure

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33064/53crscsh8124

Keywords:

defense of the territoriy, dialogism, foreclosure, polyphony

Abstract

In 2005, in the city of Zapopan, Jalisco; cracks opened up that put the inhabitants of the region at risk. To relocate these people, the municipality decided to cut down hundreds of mature oak trees in a native forest, El Nixticuil, which led to a citizen mobilization to defend the territory. Protection of the area was achieved, but this did not stop the devastation of the forest. An analysis is made of the accounts of different people who acted in the defense, to understand how they understand the defense of the territory, showing tensions and alliances that take center stage and displace the forest. In the resulting polyphony, the verbs that each character uses in relation to the struggle are analyzed to show the place of the forest in their actions. The analysis is complemented by Berque's theoretical proposal of landscape thinking that ‘closes the door’ to the medial quality of humans and is congruent with the metapsychology of psychosis. It thus outlines a possible response to understand the widespread apathy in the face of the ecosocial crisis.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Olivia Guadalupe Penilla Núñez, ITESO

Doctora en Ciencias Sociales con especialidad en Antropología Social por CIESAS. Profesora titular del Departamento de Psicología, Educación y Salud de ITESO. Participa en la línea de investigación en Psicología Social y Cultural. Temas de interés: intersubjetividad, narrativas, relación humano-ambiental, tejido ecosocial, transdisciplina autoetnografía.

References

Álvarez, S. (invierno, 2020) Crisis ecosocial, tecnociencia e implicaciones geopolíticas. Tiempo de paz,139, 107-115

Bajtin, M. 2000. Yo también soy. Fragmentos sobre el otro. Taurus.

Berque, A. (2000) Watsuji Tetsurô definition of mediance as “the structural moment of human existence” and its meaning for geography today. En Kikan chirigaku (Quarterly Journal of Geography, The Tohoku Geographical Association), 52(3), 239-244.

Berque, A. (2009) El pensamiento paisajero. Biblioteca Nueva.

Cabral, A. (2015). Participación ciudadana en la construcción de políticas públicas: una perspectiva socio-ambiental del Bosque el Nixticuil en Zapopan, Jalisco [Tesis de licenciatura no publicada]. Universidad de Guadalajara.

De la Mora, G. Y Montaño, R. (marzo-agosto, 2016) ¿Hacia la construcción de una gobernanza ambiental participativa? Estudio de caso en Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara. En Intersticios sociales, 11 https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=421744677008

Freud, S. (2000/1923). Mas allá del principio de placer. Obras completas. T. XVIII. Amorrortu

Lacan, J. (2008) El seminario 3. Las psicosis. Paidós.

Penilla, O. (2020) Narrativas del Nixticuil. Experiencias desde un bosque periurbano [Tesis de doctorado no publicada]. CIESAS.

Ricoeur, P. (2000) Narratividad, fenomenología y hermenéutica. Anàlisi, 25, 189-207.

Todorov, T. (2017/1981). Mijail Bajtin. El principio dialógico. Sello Editorial Instituto Caro y Cuervo.

Watsuji, T. (2006) Antropología del paisaje. Climas, culturas y religiones. (Fûdo: ningengakuteki kôsatsu). Ediciones Sígueme.

Published

2026-02-11 — Updated on 2026-02-19

Versions

How to Cite

Penilla Núñez, O. G. (2026). Defending the Nixticuil Forest: Polyphonic Story of a Foreclosure. Caleidoscopio - Biannual Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 29(53), 1–22. https://doi.org/10.33064/53crscsh8124 (Original work published February 11, 2026)

Issue

Section

Articles